“Better to reign in
Hell, than serve in Heaven.”
— John Milton, Paradise Lost
I know, I know, it’s Satan’s famous line from Milton, but the
first time I heard it, it was delivered by William Shatner’s Captain Kirk in the original 1967
Star Trek episode
Space
Seed. In my frequently-inaccurate childhood memory the line belongs to Ricardo Montalban’s villainous character Khan, but thanks to
YouTube, I stand corrected: Montalban
doesn’t ever actually get to say it. Rather, with unusual subtlety for the genre, Khan, offered the choice between a comfy prison or the challenge of taming a wild planet, asks Kirk, “Have you ever read Milton?” Kirk, being a renaissance man, replies “I understand”.
Thankfully for my fascinated pre-teen self (and most of the audience, I’d suspect), Kirk later explains the significance of the reference to his engineer Scotty (who, despite spectacular feats of speed-engineering, is apparently not a renaissance man).
And really, it’s Shatner, so who better to deliver the line?
But that line stuck in my head. I thought it was really cool,
and defiant, and independent, and all those things the TV screenwriters thought
it was supposed to evoke (hey, I was probably twelve, okay?). Anyway,
it worked.
But whether you choose to attribute the line to Kirk, Khan, Milton or Satan himself, it’s still wrong: Nobody reigns in hell.