“Are visions of Mary real?”
Now, here is an interesting question, and I will admit
right up front that I can’t possibly answer it as asked.
When we ask whether a thing is real, we may be asking any of
several different questions about it. We may be asking “Did this person
actually experience what they say they experienced, or is their claim
fraudulent?” Or we may be asking “Assuming they did experience something, was
it something that originated with God, or are they deceived about its origin?”
Finally, and most importantly, we may be asking “Is what they say they saw
authoritative in any way? Does it mean anything to me, or is it just an
interesting story?”