Wednesday, November 18, 2026

A Coin with Two Sides

I watched a period of NFL overtime last week. The designated captains of each team came to center field to meet the referee, who then produced a coin. He allowed the winner of the coin toss to choose whether to kick the ball to the other team or to receive it. NFL rules give the visiting team captain the right to call the toss: heads or tails. In order for the outcome to be transparent, the referee showed both captains each side of the coin. “See, the coin is legit.”

The instructions to Christians in local churches in 1 Peter 5 are like a coin with two legit but different sides: the Lord has designed them to produce the best possible outcome, and they are right there for everyone to see.

Older and Younger

The “coin” that determines the role of each “team” in a local church has different images on its two faces, and therefore distinct roles for each. We start with the well-known instructions to elders to shepherd the flock without domineering, but by being examples to the sheep. That’s side one. Flip the coin, and Peter follows that command with instructions to the younger men and women to subject themselves to the elders.

It should be obvious that nobody needs to be subject when the instructions they receive are pleasing or at least palatable to them. “Hey, great idea!” has no submission component. Voluntary subjection only becomes necessary when the younger members of the local church perceive the elders’ directions as unreasonable, poorly conceived or likely to turn out badly, and would prefer the shepherds modify them to suit the sheep. Time may prove the elders right, or even the youngsters. Yet when the church is operating the way it should, subjection of the younger is the way to go. Scripture is not ambiguous about that.

The fact that shepherds in a local church are to be examples does not mean the sheep should consider their instructions optional. In fact, their godly example, hard work and refusal to bark out the orders just to please themselves ought to make submitting to them easier for us. When we see men serving God’s people graciously and modeling the behaviors they require of others, it’s difficult to charge them with hypocrisy while keeping a straight face.

A Blanket Instruction

So the coin has two sides: a role for the elders and a role for those who are not. Different roles, but playing the role designated on your side of the coin should — at least in theory — produce the best possible outcome. It does, provided both teams play their God-given parts.

Peter then follows these first two sets of instructions with blanket instructions to both “teams”:

“Clothe yourselves, all of you, with humility toward one another, for ‘God opposes the proud but gives grace to the humble.’

Humble yourselves, therefore, under the mighty hand of God so that at the proper time he may exalt you, casting all your anxieties on him, because he cares for you.”

These two sentences apply to everyone in the local church. The words “all of you” are not difficult to parse. They mean “everybody we are currently discussing”, elders and non-elders alike. Some in the congregation may not like how their elders are ruling. An elder may not like the spirit in which some members of the congregation receive his direction. Both situations require humility and waiting on the Lord that at the proper time he may exalt the person who has his mind, assuming there is one. That’s “at the proper time”, not right this moment.

Necessary Inequality

The NFL’s overtime rules permit the visiting team to call the toss. That’s a necessary inequality. Presumably, it goes some small way toward mitigating what we call “home advantage”, the reality that the home team knows the field and the stadium far better than the visiting team and can occasionally make productive use of that knowledge. Moreover, the home team has a stadium full of crazed fans cheering them on, which the visiting team generally does not.

Agreement would make that “necessary inequality” in the overtime coin toss unnecessary, of course. If Team A instinctively called heads and Team B instinctively asked for tails, both teams could have their input and receive their preference. But the NFL shrewdly observed that would give them no answer for the situation in which both teams call heads or both teams call tails at the same time, an inconvenience that could make the coin toss drag on interminably. In order for the process to operate efficiently, one party has to initiate (by calling the toss) and the other has to accept the outcome despite getting no input into the choice.

So the visiting team gets to call the toss, even if the home team would prefer to, because those are the rules of the game. The appearance of rigid fairness must sometimes be subordinated to functionality. The big picture is more important than the wishes of either team.

Initiating and Responding

In the local church, elders are like the visiting team in the coin toss: they get to initiate. In a small way, that “necessary inequity” mitigates a disadvantage every man in church leadership starts his service for God knowing about: that he will be judged more strictly by God. He may also be judged more strictly by men. An elder’s sins, when they occur, put him at risk of public rebuke in front of the congregation in a way that the sins of others need not. An elder also has to qualify for service according to a set of objective standards to which some men in the local church may not trouble themselves to attain, or perhaps cannot because of circumstances. Like the NFL’s rules, the “inequity” of one group getting to initiate turns out on closer examination to be not quite so inequitable as it appears.

This is where Peter’s instructions to both “teams” about humility come in. NFL players don’t re-litigate the rules of the game every time a coin is about to be tossed. By showing up to play the game, they accept that it will be played under the rules, like them or not. Any player may personally disagree with certain aspects of the rules, and sometimes you find these debates online, but subjection to the rules of the sport as currently written is an assumption so basic nobody even discusses it during a game. You do not get to play if you refuse to accept what’s in the rulebook.

Humility as the Key

Likewise, humility toward one another is the default position for everyone in a local church. God did not design his body to operate optimally when men perpetually insist on their own way. “My way or the highway” is a foreign spirit to those in the process of being made over in the likeness of Christ. The church is no place for arrogant elders or insubordinate congregants, especially because there is no easy way to resolve such conflicts without humility, or to remove those who refuse to display it.

Think about it: a charge of drunkenness, heresy or sexual immorality against an elder is easy to substantiate, but a charge of arrogance not so much. Arrogance is attitudinal, more easily concealed and much harder to prove. Unless you are a prophet or God himself, judging arrogance in others usually requires making assumptions or projecting, both of which can be spiritually hazardous. Without humility in his elders, a younger man’s hands are tied, even if he is the more spiritual individual and his cause is right.

Likewise, elders have little biblical recourse when members of the congregation opt to ignore their instructions without engaging in direct, unpleasant confrontation. A local church can (and should) put a man or woman out of the congregation for aggressive behavior, drunkenness, theft or immorality, but what can you do with a man or woman who is perpetually and cheerily uncompliant? Prayer or a gentle appeal are really the only useful options.

In the local church, the coin has two sides: it needs both humble shepherds and humble sheep. God has designed roles for each of us. If we are seeking his will, it’s up to us to play them. The best place for a person who perpetually refuses to clothe himself with humility toward others is outside the church. The sooner he realizes it, the better for all.

No comments :

Post a Comment