Most new marriages come packaged with one or two “problem friends”, by which I mean long-term relationships one spouse has with individuals the other spouse dislikes with sufficient intensity that they would be happier if their new partner in life never saw that person again. Perhaps it’s an old high school or university pal whose behavior is something less than squeaky clean and Christian. The new spouse observes that this person is a bad influence. Their partner either doesn’t see the problem or sees it and is unwilling to disengage regardless.
Add the likelihood of impressionable children to the mix down the road, and you’ve got the potential for simmering domestic conflict, and the need to address the problem early on.
We did a post on toxic influences earlier this month that revolved primarily around conflicts with extended family members, and what should and shouldn’t be done about them. We ran another in September about the difficulties the example of unsaved relatives can pose for children, especially when these cads have appealing qualities that flavor their worldliness. Some problem relationships are near-obligatory, say in the case of immediate family, though they may need serious management. Others have more flexibility, the problem friend among them.
We Just Disagree
When I see Christians struggling with this issue in online forums, they usually ask questions like, “How can I get my husband to stop seeing X?” or “How can I show my wife that Y is the sort of person the apostle Paul warned about in 1 Corinthians 15?” (“Do not be deceived: ‘Bad company ruins good morals.’ ”) In other words, “How can I have this issue resolved my way?” Nobody asks, “Should I rethink my assessment of this person?”, “Is there a better way to handle this than just insisting my spouse cut off X or Y?” or even “Is it possible my spouse is being more godly about this than I am?” To me, the absence of self-examination is a bit of a red flag. That’s always a good starting point: asking am I “just a jealous guy”? Maybe the problem is me.
As a few of the more alert commenters point out, attempting to exert influence on their partner can too easily become manipulative, or be perceived as manipulative, straining the marriage further. Bombarding a spouse with proof texts for your point of view is certainly more direct, but equally likely to go unappreciated. Coming from a wife, it’s nagging. Coming from a husband, it’s far better when it responds to a request like, “Hon, would you mind showing me from scripture why you believe that’s the way to handle her?”
Playing the Authority Card
Thought experiment: Let’s assume the spouse is genuinely wrong about this person. They are spiritual bad news in one way or another. In a properly functioning Christian marriage, a husband could theoretically put his foot down … but should he? It seems unreasonable for a new husband to play the authority card in situation after situation when his wife has no such option, especially in modern marriages. There are times for drawing a line in the sand, no doubt, but surely not in every single case where life partners disagree. The Lord doesn’t display his authority that way with us, though he certainly could if he wanted to.
YHWH’s dealings with Israel as a sort of spousal analogy are instructive, as always. Sure, there are times the Lord acts to enforce his will and word, like sending a famine in the days of Elijah. There are also times he expresses a preference (“I hate divorce”) and allows generation after generation to ignore it with no apparent consequences beyond the inevitable sorrows and negative life changes that accompany expressions of hard-heartedness. A marriage modeled on the Lord’s relationship with Israel ought to reflect the available spectrum of divine relationship strategies, not just a convenient subset of these that serves the purposes of the spouse wearing the pants. (Hint: Fire from heaven is not usually an option.)
The Real Reason
What often goes unstated is the real reason your partner may not like some of your friends. Oh, there will be the surface reason: “He drinks too much”, “He has a foul mouth” or “He’s a white nationalist.” If the shoe is on the other foot, it may be “She’s a feminist harpy” or “She talks trash about her husband every time she’s around.” These are usually white noise.
The unstated reason your problem friend unsettles your wife or husband is usually much more alarming and personal than the occasional unexpected home invasion from an unsavory individual. It’s that they believe they see changes in you whenever that problem friend is around, and those changes make them feel vulnerable or uncomfortable. Your problem friend makes them view you differently in ways that probably do not flatter you.
Sometimes this is a perception issue; jealousy of a shared history of which your spouse played no part. They feel left out of something they could never have been part of in the first place. At such times, the “problem” with your problem friend may be primarily between your partner’s ears. Other times it may be real. Jealousy in a marriage may at times be completely justifiable. Your spouse may be observing something not so wonderful about you of which you are completely unaware: a tendency to cowardice or distasteful subservience, secrets you have never discussed, interests and experiences you probably shouldn’t have had. Those are not the “good old days”, and the fact that your spouse does not revel in them with you and your old friend is understandable and normal. You are letting your spouse and the Lord down at the same time as your testimony falters.
Roles and Dynamics
We’ve all overheard a friend or family member talking to someone on the phone and registered instantly that the third party impresses or attracts them. Their facial expression and manner of speech changes. They feign interest in subjects you know they don’t give a fig about. Their body language is abnormal. Names and places come up that you’ve never heard of. Nobody has to tell you the person at the other end of the call is exerting a strong influence on your friend. You can see it for yourself. It’s unmistakable. Observant wives and husbands do the same thing when they see you relating to old friends, usually a lot quicker than teens eavesdropping. They know your habits and patterns well. When these change for somebody else, it’s unsettling.
To be fair, we all play a variety of roles in life and each of these involves different relationship dynamics. At the office, you may play trusted right-hand man to an alpha boss. That’s a different role than you play at home with your wife. Hopefully. In turn, that differs from the relationship dynamic you have with your neighbor over the fence. Also hopefully.
That sort of morphing role assumption is normal and appropriate. What’s not normal or appropriate is when any particular relationship dynamic results in you talking out both sides of your mouth, compromising your professed values, or behaving in ways your spouse does not recognize.
Forsaking All Others
Most marriage vows still include the phrase “forsaking all others”. That solemn promise derives its spiritual authority from Genesis 2:24, the “leave and cleave” verse. In Genesis, the man (or woman) is not pledging to forsake all future sexual opportunities outside marriage that life may present, though that is surely implicit. God’s prescription is actually about forsaking the parental relationship, one of the strongest natural bonds there is, to whatever extent the new marriage relationship requires it. How much more should we be willing to vigorously and unilaterally redefine any pre-existing friendship that poses a genuine threat to the comfort and well-being of a spouse.
I’m not suggesting every “problem friend” needs to be summarily cut off. That’s neither loyal nor particularly Christian. But depending on the seriousness of the problem they pose for your spouse, the role they play in your life may have to change significantly. That’s part of the package in any good marriage, and it’s one few young couples plan for going in.

No comments :
Post a Comment