The most recent version of this post is available here.
- Home
- What We’re Doing Here
- F A Q
- 119
- Anonymous Asks
- Book Reviews
- The Commentariat Speaks
- Doesn’t Always Mean What We Think It Means
- Flyover Country
- How Not to Crash and Burn
- Inbox
- Just Church
- The Language of the Debate
- Mining the Minors
- No King in Israel
- On the Mount
- Quote of the Day
- Recommend-a-blog
- Semi-Random Musings
- That Wacky Old Testament
- Time and Chance
- What Does Your Proof Text Prove?
Friday, March 20, 2020
Thursday, March 19, 2020
Youth Problems Part 1: Double Jeopardy
The most recent version of this post is available here.
Labels:
Christianity
/
Faith
/
Growing Up
/
Youth
Wednesday, March 18, 2020
Stricken Sheep
“Then David spoke to the Lord when he saw the angel who was
striking the people, and said, ‘Behold, I have sinned, and I have
done wickedly. But these sheep, what have they done?’ ”
People who are characteristically righteous always have an
outsized sense of their own relative culpability. That is probably a good
thing. A tender conscience toward sin and a heart which always looks to get
right with God are qualities to be valued and pursued. God is often more
generous with his assessment of righteous men and women than they are with
themselves.
But a preoccupation with our own personal responsibility can
also be a bit like wearing blinders.
Tuesday, March 17, 2020
The Commentariat Speaks (18)
“Are you one of those people who say that
there are actually two different Gog and Magog events?”
Good question. I may have looked into it before, but my last serious attempt to unpack Bible
prophecy in detail was way back in the nineties. I wouldn’t attempt to
answer a question like that without going back to the scriptures and refreshing
my memory. So I begged off answering until I had time to take a more careful
look at the text.
This week I had plenty.
Labels:
Dispensationalism
/
Magog
/
Premillennialism
/
The Commentariat Speaks
Monday, March 16, 2020
Anonymous Asks (84)
“Does Christianity need to develop a new gospel adapted to today’s world?”
If the Christian faith was merely the invention of man, and
if Christians were permitted to market it to the world in whatever way seems
like it might work best, this could be a good idea. After all, brands grow
stale over time and need to be refreshed. And in a consumer world, it’s
whatever makes the sale for you. The customer is always right.
In this case, however, the “customer” is going to hell.
Labels:
Anonymous Asks
/
Gospel
/
Witnessing
Sunday, March 15, 2020
Satan Unleashed
A reader of the book of Revelation writes:
“Doesn’t the Pre-Mill version of Satan’s release seem weird? In it
Jesus has physically ruled over the nations for a thousand years. Don’t you
think they’d have learned something? And then Satan just waltzes out of his
prison, goes, ‘Hi, it’s me, your old pal Satan!’ and EVERY nation goes, ‘WE LOVE
YOU SATAN, LEAD US PLZ!!’ I mean, how long does it take to get to that
point? A few weeks? A month? How does that work?
In the Pre-Mill view, doesn’t it also seem weird that the nations don’t
go, ‘Wait, things are happening JUST like in that book Jesus has been talking
about for a millennium. But hey, following Satan still seems like the best
idea!’ How could they possibly get confused over this?”
The way a reader reacts to Satan’s release and the events
which follow it in Revelation 20:7 very much depends on what he believes
about the Millennium: its intended purpose(s), its governing conditions, and the
people over whom Jesus Christ will rule.
Personally, I find the reaction of the nations in
Revelation 20 all too plausible.
Labels:
Dispensationalism
/
Millennium
/
Satan
Saturday, March 14, 2020
Time and Chance (27)
If we took the first thirteen verses of Ecclesiastes 7 on their own, we might initially think
they belong in the book of Proverbs. They are fairly standard Hebrew proverbial
couplets (with the occasional interjection).
This is not the first time the form is used in Ecclesiastes. There are a few couplets sprinkled
through chapters 1, 4 and 5, and we will encounter more in chapters 8,
10 and 11.
What is different about the proverbs we find in Ecclesiastes in that they do not skip around from
subject to subject with anything like their usual apparent randomness, but
instead serve the book’s larger treatise. They are thematically linked to one
another, to what comes before them, and to what follows them.
Labels:
Death
/
Ecclesiastes
/
Time and Chance
Friday, March 13, 2020
Too Hot to Handle: Break Out the Marshmallows
In which our regular writers toss around
subjects a little more volatile than usual.
This is an interesting take. The Independent brings us the story of Joseph Atwill, who has written a book entitled Caesar’s Messiah: The Roman Conspiracy to Invent Jesus.
Atwill says Christianity is actually a
“system of mind control” developed by the Romans to “produce slaves that
believe God actually decreed their slavery.”
Tom: Who knew, Immanuel Can? Our whole faith is nothing more than the product of a first century propaganda campaign. Fortunately someone finally figured that out for us. Or not.
Labels:
Incarnation Myths
/
Recycling
/
Too Hot to Handle
Thursday, March 12, 2020
Wednesday, March 11, 2020
The Commentariat Speaks (17)
A Baptist pastor weighs in on the question of when the
church began:
“The church didn’t begin at Pentecost, it began when God called Abram out of Ur of the Chaldees. All who believe are descendants of his promise.
Nothing has stopped his church for over 4000 years and nothing can.”
Reply to this sort of thing in 180 characters? You have to
be kidding. It’s one reason certain social media platforms are inferior places
for Christian discussion. They foster snappy rhetorical flourishes, but
discourage nuanced analysis. That doesn’t make them useless, but it certainly
limits their usefulness.
I suppose one might reply, “It depends how you define ‘church’.”
That may get the attentive reader thinking. Or not. So let’s try something
a little longer-form.
Labels:
Church
/
Pentecost
/
The Commentariat Speaks
Tuesday, March 10, 2020
Not An Idiot
The books of Chronicles cover much of the same historical
material we find in the books of Samuel and Kings, sometimes in near-identical
wording. This provokes legitimate questions: Do we need both? Our Bibles are
bulky enough already without including a whole lot of duplicated material. What
do the books of Chronicles offer us that Samuel and Kings do not?
There are several possible responses to those questions, but
the short answers are “Yes” and “Quite a bit.” I am working on a
comparative study of the two sets of narratives and hope to get into that
subject more extensively later this year in this space if time permits. Though
more or less the same time periods are covered, there are numerous variations
in content and wording that make each account useful to readers in different
ways.
Labels:
1 Chronicles
/
2 Samuel
/
Contradictions in Scripture
Monday, March 09, 2020
Anonymous Asks (83)
“Why isn’t the Bible in chronological order?”
If the Bible were nothing more than a history text, organizing it chronologically would be perfectly
sensible. But when you have a book that contains history, law, poetry, wisdom
literature, prophecy and moral teaching that interprets history for us, the
question becomes considerably more complicated.
Labels:
Anonymous Asks
/
Bible
/
Bible Study
Sunday, March 08, 2020
Under the Tower of Siloam
Individual guilt differs
from corporate guilt, and individual repentance from corporate repentance, not
just quantitatively but qualitatively.
That’s going to require a
fair bit of explanation, especially for Christian readers born into our
hyper-individualistic Western culture. Most of us only think about the matter
of corporate guilt when we find ourselves summarily dismissing Progressivist
ravings about race- or gender-based privilege. We rightly reject being held
responsible for the long-term social impact of patterns of historical behavior in which we have
never engaged and from which we do not personally benefit. “Each of us will
give an account of himself to
God,” we say.
Full stop, move along now.
Labels:
Guilt
/
Luke
/
Nationalism
/
Repentance
Saturday, March 07, 2020
Time and Chance (26)
The much-maligned Donald
Rumsfeld, former U.S. Secretary of Defense under President George W. Bush, once
said this: “There are known knowns. These are things we know that we know.
There are known unknowns. That is to say, there are things that we know we don’t
know. But there are also unknown unknowns. There are things we don’t know we
don’t know.”
That may sound like bafflegab, but it’s actually a fairly lucid breakdown of the possibilities.
Labels:
Ecclesiastes
/
Life
/
Time and Chance
Friday, March 06, 2020
Too Hot to Handle: The Dwarves are for the Dwarves
In which our regular writers toss around
subjects a little more volatile than usual.
The term “postmodern” is not actually all
that modern. John Watkins Chapman used it in the 1880s in relation to art criticism. Umberto Eco has said that postmodernism is less a style or a period than an “attitude”.
The attitude comes out clearly in what is produced by postmodernists in their various fields: postmodern graphic design disdains traditional conventions such as legibility; postmodern music rejects beauty and sometimes structure; postmodern philosophers reject the concepts of subjectivity and objectivity. You get the general idea.
Tom: Immanuel Can, help me nail it down: what is postmodernism?
Labels:
Postmodernism
/
Recycling
/
Too Hot to Handle
/
Worldviews
Thursday, March 05, 2020
Two Glories
The most recent version of this post is available here.
Labels:
David
/
Glory
/
Mephibosheth
/
Worship
Wednesday, March 04, 2020
John Piper’s God
John Piper’s God is not someone I find particularly
appealing.
Piper’s Calvinist determinism makes his version of heaven a
scary place where every microscopic detail of human existence is examined, and from
which God himself administers rough justice to his subjects on the spot as he
sees fit, to believers and unbelievers alike, sometimes in the form of
really bad weather.
A rash of tornados across the U.S. in 2012 prompted Piper to
express his opinion in this post.
Labels:
Determinism
/
John Piper
/
Judgment
/
Neo-Calvinism
Tuesday, March 03, 2020
Of Generals and Foot Soldiers
“Seek his kingdom, and these things will be added to you.”
Here is a tall order, no? How exactly do we seek God’s
kingdom?
Oh, I know we all have some kind of mental picture in view
when we pray “Thy kingdom come.” I certainly always do. During the eight years
of Barack Obama’s stewardship of the U.S., I regularly imagined the man’s
surprise at getting his just desserts one day. I look forward to all
deceivers being shown to the world for exactly what they are: right, left and
apolitical alike. I picture the enthroned Christ dispensing justice, the
wolf lying down with the lamb, and ultimate truth, love and discernment
dictating all aspects of world governance.
There are all kinds of ways we may picture the kingdom. But
seeking it? That’s something else. It seems like the sort of aspiration in
which one’s reach easily exceeds one’s grasp.
Labels:
Kingdom
/
Luke
/
Spiritual Warfare
Monday, March 02, 2020
Anonymous Asks (82)
“Should I wait for God to bring me a boyfriend?”
Let’s apply this “wait for God” principle to a few of life’s other important questions and consider
how much sense it makes, as well as the mostly likely outcome of waiting:
“Should I wait for God to deliver dinner?” (Starvation)
“Should I wait for God to provide me with a job?” (Chronic unemployment)
“Should I wait for God to wash my car?” (An unspeakably filthy vehicle)
Labels:
Anonymous Asks
/
Providence
/
Relationships
Sunday, March 01, 2020
Crazed Swine on a Gerasene Hillside
We do not have a whole lot of clear teaching in the Bible
about demons and precisely how they operate. It is evident from the various
accounts we have in the gospels that demons are capable of indwelling, tormenting
and periodically controlling humans who become susceptible to them, but we do
not know much more than this for certain.
Under what conditions do demons come and indwell a person? Where do
they go when they haven’t got a human being to play with? Why do they so
terribly fear the abyss, and what makes them crave human hosts while methodically working away at their destruction? None of these things are spelled out for us.
Labels:
Demon Possession
/
Demons
/
Luke
Subscribe to:
Posts
(
Atom
)